What About Polygamy?

Martha Nussbaum:

What is wrong with polygamy?

Nineteenth-century Americans coupled it with slavery, calling both “the twin relics of barbarism.” Today, it is used as a scare image to deter people from approving same-sex marriage, lest it lead down a slippery slope to that horror of horrors.

But what, exactly, is bad about it? Looking at the Texas sect at the Yearning for Zion ranch, so much in the news, will not tell us, because that sect allegedly forced underage girls into marriage. The case then becomes one of child sexual abuse, a crime hardly unknown in the monogamous family, although it gets less splashy publicity when it occurs there. Disturbing things are fun to contemplate when they can be pinned on distant “deviants,” but threatening when they occur in families like one’s own.

Mormon polygamy of the 19th century was not child abuse. Adult women married by consent, and typically lived in separate dwellings, each visited by the husband in turn. In addition to their theological rationale, Mormons defended the practice with social arguments – in particular that polygamous men would abandon wives or visit prostitutes less frequently. Instead of answering these arguments, however, Americans hastened to vilify Mormon society, publishing semi-pornographic novels that depicted polygamy as a hotbed of incest and child abuse.

Read the rest here

4 thoughts on “What About Polygamy?

  1. Yes, I read in the SMH today something about Muslim leaders condoning rape, domestic violence…and polygamy. Um…one of these things is not like the other!!? I think I’m off to post on that in fact!

  2. HI! I’m so happy to see you. 🙂 I’ll look for your post. I do have problems with the concept of polygamy, but at the same time, it seems hardly worse than the matter of de facto serial monogamy and infidelity that characterizes heterosexual “marriage”. So, what the hell?

  3. Yeah,no me too! I guess it’s not the idea of multiple partners that is *bad*, it’s other stuff layered onto it…I mean I’ve never heard of a polygamous set up where there’s one woman and many men, or one woman and a gaggle of different genders. I suppose that’s cos we supposedly don’t care for sex! Pht. It’s certainly not my finest point.
    You’re a very prolific poster! I come by to check in but can’t keep up! But I always enjoy what I read.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s